Two Hives In One

I am going though all of my hives right now – more on the “what I do” in the next blog – but I thought my “two hives in one” moment was quite interesting.


Last year I took part in a bee health survey .  The last month I was willing to run a test was in October.  I never open my hives in October – it is just too cold.  But I wanted to know if the natural treatments I use really work (last year: Nozevit and Mite Away Quick Strips – formic acid).   The results are here.

All of the eight hives I tested still had eggs and/or brood, except one.

So there I am, worrying: does this hive, a really strong hive, have a queen?

As I have mentioned, to say “Karen worries” is about like saying “The earth revolves around the sun”.  It’s a given; I worry.

Next to this hive is a nuc with a nice little queen.  It was a good nuc, but not big enough to make it though the winter.

That evening, using the newspaper method, I merged the two hives. I did not move anything in either hive.  This means that the nuc went above a box with 6 frames of honey in the center and 4 empty frames on the side – I figured if the lower bees needed a queen, they would come find her.

A week later I pulled the newspaper, thinking, “Well, I’ve either saved a hive or condemned the weaker queen to death”.  Then I went home and winter set in.

A tall hive at a Brookfield Farm bee yard, Maple Flls, Washington

The tall hive
Room for 2 queens


This week, I was working down the hives in that bee yard.  At that moment I’d totally forgotten about the merge.  I do keep notes; I just hadn’t read them.

I pulled the top off of the hive and there was a nice little cluster.

Brookfield Farm top bee box in over winter check

Top Bee Box
Small Cluster With Queen










I don’t expect, or want, big clusters here at this time of year.  We’re still about a month away from any substantial nectar flow, and it’s raining about 50% of the time.  I just like so see a nice cluster with some eggs and possibly brood.

I set the top box, with eggs, and probably the queen, aside and start down the boxes (it was a really tall hive due to the merge).

Next box down – fairly empty, some honey.  Set it aside.

Checking over wintered bees - box 2

The second box down









Next box – lots of honey.  Pick it up to set aside.

Brookfield Farm bee box during post winter check

3rd Box down :
filled with honey










And see in the next box:

Brookfield Farm bee box with strong cluster

The second queen
Fourth Box Down











– a substantial cluster of bees.  “What the????” I thought, and then remembered the merge.


I gently open these frames, and sure enough there’s eggs and brood down there too.

I am elated, and grumpy.  The elation is obvious: I’ve got two good hives in one.  The grump was because I was tired.  It was the end of the day, I had one more hive to go, and now I’d have to come back after dark and move the upper queen and her boxes.

Because the merge had taken place over a “wall” of honey, the two hives lived happily together.  Bees really don’t like to cross solid honey unless there’s a reason.  Had the bottom box been queenless, those bees would have had a reason to head for the queen upstairs.


I did have that one last hive to work.  So, after tidying up the two-queen hive, I rebuilt it with its wall of honey in place, knowing I’d come back later.

The next hive was grumpier than I.  There were lots of bees, but they were not pleased.  I soon discovered why:  they had no queen.  She must have recently died, as there were no laying workers.  Just lots and lots of angry ones.

So I cheated.  It was late, but not dark.  Foragers were still out.  I picked up the top queen-right boxes from my two-queen hive, and merged them, and their queen, with the queenless hive.  I always have newspaper with me for these emergencies.

Brookfield Farm Bee yard : two bee boxes being merged

The Merge










I figured the foragers from the queen-right boxes would go back to what had been the 2-queen hive.  But the queenless hive had more than enough workers so I think they’ll be fine.

I’ll head back this week (when it stops raining), and pull the newspaper.


One of the things I like about beekeeping is its surprises and challenges.  I never know what I’m going to encounter when I open a hive.  Sometimes it’s depressing (the bees are there, but they’re dead), and sometimes, like this, it is joyful.  Keeps me on my toes.

Any surprises in your hives?  Do tell – beekeeping has so many mysteries – and they are all fascinating.

About brookfieldfarmhoney

Brookfield Farm, a small off-grid apiary in Maple Falls, WA focuses on the beauty and bounties of Washington’s wilderness. I sell honey from our bees, whose naturally-treated, antibiotic-free hives are home to bees who fly Washington’s mountains and farmlands. Herbal salves and lip balms from Brookfield beeswax. Delicately infused honeys and vinegars. Varietal honeys from independent Washington beekeepers. Karen Edmundson Bean: beekeeper, photographer. Her love of the wilderness inspires her to discover new ways of bringing the wonders of nature to others. Brookfield Farm : the tastes, textures, sounds, and images of nature.
This entry was posted in 1 Beekeeping, 5 Queens and Queen Rearing, 9 Brookfield Farm Bee Yards and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Two Hives In One

  1. As my beekeeping 101 teacher said, the bees do not read the same books we do! Glad both your queens came through…you know we had a really dry, warm fall last year and your lower hive queen may just have stopped laying in that dearth?

    • I think the majority of my queens stop laying around September, when the scouts and foragers “tell” the hive “there’s nothing out there, shut the queen down until we can get more food”… I have russians, new world Carniolans, and ferals – all of whom overwinter in smaller clusters – That’s what I like about them. so, I figure that the bees & queen in the lower hive were on the right track and I, the worried beekeeper, over-reacted and tossed the other hive on. At least the upper hive had in-floor heating all winter.

  2. Emily Heath says:

    Fun! Let us know how the combining goes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s